15:29 <mntmn> MSAA is not supported on GC7000L (with etnaviv), right?

15:30 <cphealy> I think MSAA is enabled but crashes things ATM.

15:30 <austriancoder> mntmn: msaa does not work on any gpu

15:30 <cphealy> I've got a patch that disables it so third party apps don't try to use it and crash the system.

15:30 <mntmn> ok, that is congruent with my experience

15:31 <mntmn> cphealy: ah, that would be a useful patch to have if you want to share it, then i don't need to patch the app

15:31 <austriancoder> yeah.. disabling would be the easiest thing atm

15:32 <mntmn> i was fixing kicad 3d viewer just displaying a black rectangle, and i think it was because it was asking for a sample buffer (not even using it)

15:32 <mntmn> like, removing the sample buffer from the attributes made things work

15:33 <mntmn> but now i'm stumbling over GL_ALPHA_TEST again. maybe it's time to fix that.

15:33 <mntmn> maybe it's a similar situation where bits for it are now in a different place?

15:33 <cphealy> https://pastebin.com/eEWAewfe

15:34 <mntmn> cphealy: cool, thanks!

15:35 <austriancoder> cphealy: create an MR and we can land it in master and some stable versions

15:41 <cphealy> austriancoder: Does it make sense to have that upstream? TBH, it's just a hack that lynxeye created for me to work around it not working.

15:43 <austriancoder> cphealy: it does make sense as we report something that's broken add we cause problems for apps

15:47 <mntmn> yes, i also would say it's better not to advertise things that don't work

15:47 <mntmn> for example it could have saved me 2-3 evenings of fiddling around ;)

15:48 <cphealy> ack

16:42 <daniels> hmm, I thought Gert fixed MSAA for at least some GPUs (GC700?) and it was already working on others (GC880?)

16:43 <austriancoder> daniels: was more or less only wip stuff (with problems)

16:44 <daniels> shame, looking at it there's no outstanding review comments from anyone and no indication (other than it still not passing all of dEQP) that it makes things worse and shouldn't be merged

16:47 <daniels> https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mesa/mesa/-/merge_requests/2961

16:47 <austriancoder> daniels: some little things regarding msaa landed... but ther is still some work that needs to be done

16:49 <austriancoder> daniels: so let's disable msaa untils it is really fixed

16:50 <daniels> sure

16:50 <daniels> would be nice to know what it is that should be fixed