03:22 <chadmed> janneg: speakersafetyd and asahi-audio done now too

11:52 <stintel> ooh nice

13:02 <tobhe_> chadmed: I was wondering, speakersafetyd lists minimum version requirements for wireplumber and pipewire in the readme. Are those actually hard requirements or just the oldest you tested?

13:03 <chadmed> tobhe_: important patches for asahi-audio landed in those versions so we're not supporting anything below

13:04 <tobhe_> ah right, s/speakersafetyd/asahi-audio/ I meant.

13:04 <chadmed> speakersafetyd itself shouldnt care, but the DSP graphs, util clamping stuff, etc simply will not work at all if your version is out of date

13:04 <chadmed> yeah thought so

13:04 <tobhe_> I am asking because I wonder if it makes sense to backport those patches instead of the full thing

13:05 <tobhe_> I did already include this one https://git.launchpad.net/~tobhe/ubuntu/+source/wireplumber/commit/?h=ubuntu/mantic-asahi&id=f0da3810aa54b93bcd829f2b373944558ed621d9

13:05 <chadmed> theyre pretty small so they should be fine to backport

13:06 <chadmed> youll also need https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/pipewire/-/commit/70d2b0eeb4c6e16de91e952b0715543d54190f44

13:07 <chadmed> https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/pipewire/-/commit/fd969dab2878836fd8e9ac7d8fb92d1ede594f37

13:07 <chadmed> https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/pipewire/-/commit/89e9da8cc0e78c29a46906f2f27f035d5a5cc2a4

13:08 <tobhe_> thx! looks doable

13:08 <chadmed> https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/pipewire/-/commit/eca48223118e3a26a5d89b9aba79b15b78fdae7e

13:08 <chadmed> https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/pipewire/-/commit/2d6fcf4c848ca130f0d6df97ac8d78e51d5d38f0

13:08 <chadmed> https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/pipewire/-/commit/cf44bf73da9dfd45ee7e78a9e8fc077b170f242c

13:08 <chadmed> https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/pipewire/-/commit/4d159fa1db3f9cc7b6193e25ef481e5e282034da

13:08 <chadmed> and for wireplumber

13:09 <chadmed> https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/wireplumber/-/commit/7394f478d6aba3dc51026a9854813a48f2332da0

13:09 <chadmed> https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/wireplumber/-/commit/3fa87510d1f523901c41039f39522f5c48989e54

13:09 <chadmed> and then everything dmitry sharshakov did from 0.4.15 and earlier

13:09 <chadmed> im not going to spam the logs with more links

13:10 <tobhe_> that's fine :)

13:10 <tobhe_> thanks! that was very helpful

13:10 <chadmed> what versions are shipped with mantic?

13:11 <tobhe_> wp = 0.4.14

13:11 <tobhe_> pipewire = 0.3.79

13:11 <chadmed> yeesh ok

13:11 <chadmed> wireplumber will probably be fine

13:11 <chadmed> pipewire might be a struggle

13:12 <tobhe_> if it turns out to be too much work I'll just see if I can import the newest debian version

14:21 <stintel> haha you folks are describing the reason I run gentoo

14:26 <mps> does speakersafetyd in current works without pipewire, i.e. on plain alsa

17:24 <ahdeb[m]> mps (IRC): as far as I understand, yes - speakersafetyd only uses alsa not pipewire.

17:37 <mps> ahdeb[m]: this is also my understanding, but wasn't sure. thanks

22:32 <chadmed> mps: it works but keep in mind that we wont be offering any support for nonstandard speaker setups